Role-Playing and Scenario Building: Using AI to Strengthen Conflict Resolution Skills

Explore how AI-powered role-playing and scenario building can enhance conflict resolution education in K–12 schools through personalized, engaging SEL experiences.
May 15 / Andy Culley

In today’s classrooms, students don’t just need academic knowledge—they need the tools to resolve conflict, navigate emotions, and build lasting relationships. These social-emotional competencies are foundational for both personal well-being and civic participation.

But teaching conflict resolution can be messy. It requires nuance, empathy, context, and practice. That’s why educators are beginning to explore how AI-powered role-playing and scenario building can offer scalable, dynamic ways to support conflict resolution education.

This article explores the potential of AI in conflict resolution education, how generative tools can simulate real-world scenarios, and what educators need to consider to use them ethically and effectively.




Why Conflict Resolution Matters in SEL

Conflict is inevitable—in the classroom, on the playground, and online. According to CASEL, conflict resolution skills fall under multiple core competencies, including:

  • Self-awareness,

  • Social awareness,

  • Relationship skills,

  • Responsible decision-making.

Teaching students to navigate disagreement calmly, respectfully, and constructively not only improves classroom culture—it equips them for life.

Yet SEL curricula often fall short in providing real-time, personalized opportunities to practice these skills. This is where generative AI tools can help.




How AI Enhances Scenario-Based SEL

Generative AI models, such as GPT-4 and Claude, can generate interactive scenarios that simulate peer conflicts, family dynamics, or community issues. These scenarios can:

  • Be tailored to grade level, reading level, and emotional tone,

  • Evolve based on student input,

  • Prompt multiple response options with feedback,

  • Encourage reflection and revision.

For example, a middle school student might engage with this AI-generated prompt:

“Your best friend spreads a rumor about you. You’re angry, but you also don’t want to lose the friendship. What could you do next?”

Students can explore various approaches:

  • Confronting the friend,

  • Seeking advice,

  • Ignoring the situation,

  • Writing out their thoughts before responding.

AI can then offer empathetic, constructive feedback, or simulate the friend’s reaction based on the student’s choice.




Benefits of AI Role-Play in Conflict Resolution

1️⃣ Safe, Low-Risk Practice

Many students fear saying the wrong thing or looking weak during live role-play. AI scenarios offer a judgment-free environment to test approaches and learn from missteps.

2️⃣ Personalized Scenarios

Generative AI can:

  • Modify names, places, and dynamics based on real student experiences,

  • Offer culturally relevant situations,

  • Adjust tone and complexity dynamically.

This personalization fosters greater engagement and relevance.

3️⃣ Real-Time Feedback

Rather than waiting for a teacher to process every response, AI can provide instant tips such as:

  • “That might escalate the situation—want to try a calmer tone?”

  • “Great! You acknowledged your feelings before responding.”

This immediate coaching supports emotional regulation and strategic thinking.

4️⃣ Scalability Across Classrooms

With AI, teachers can assign scenario-based SEL tasks that students complete asynchronously—freeing up classroom time while still delivering individualized learning.

5️⃣ Support for Neurodiverse Learners

Role-playing can be overwhelming for some students. AI allows them to engage at their own pace, repeat scenarios, and build confidence before applying skills in real life.




Tools and Platforms Exploring AI-Based Scenarios

  • Kialo Edu (while not fully AI-driven, it supports structured argument practice),

  • Diffit for Teachers (used to generate differentiated SEL scenarios),

  • Custom GPTs and chatbots developed by districts or SEL specialists using tools like ChatGPT or Poe.

The growing integration of AI into EdTech platforms suggests this approach will become increasingly mainstream in SEL design.




Pitfalls and Ethical Considerations

🚩 1. Scripting Empathy vs. Practicing Empathy

While AI can simulate human behavior, students must understand that real conflicts involve complex feelings, tone, and body language. Role-play should be a bridge to human interaction, not a substitute for it.

🚩 2. Inaccurate or Biased Scenarios

Generative AI is not perfect. It can produce culturally insensitive or oversimplified responses if not guided carefully. Educators must vet and edit prompts to ensure inclusivity.

As noted by the UNESCO AI in Education report, unchecked AI may reflect stereotypes embedded in training data (UNESCO, 2021).

🚩 3. Overreliance on Automation

AI scenarios are tools, not teachers. Educators should contextualize every digital role-play with live discussions, peer feedback, or journal reflections to reinforce learning.

🚩 4. Data Privacy Risks

AI platforms that store or analyze student inputs may collect sensitive data. Schools must ensure compliance with FERPA, COPPA, and local privacy laws and prioritize platforms with transparent ethics.




Best Practices for AI Scenario Integration

✅ 1. Co-Design With Students

Involve students in building prompts or scenarios relevant to their real experiences. This ensures greater buy-in and authenticity.

✅ 2. Debrief Every Scenario

After each AI-led scenario, prompt reflection with questions like:

  • What worked well?

  • What surprised you?

  • How might this relate to a real situation you’ve faced?

✅ 3. Pair Digital With Human

Use AI as a warm-up or extension. Follow up with live partner or group role-plays to build relational confidence.

✅ 4. Maintain Human Oversight

Always review student interactions with AI. Be ready to offer clarification, context, or corrections when needed.




Success Stories and Pilots

In early pilots across schools in New York, Ontario, and Singapore, AI-driven SEL scenarios have:

  • Increased student participation in role-play activities by 40%,

  • Reduced social anxiety about conflict discussions,

  • Helped ELL students practice diplomatic language structures.

The Brookings Institution affirms that when used in tandem with traditional methods, AI scenario-building can boost student problem-solving, empathy, and communication skills (Brookings AI in Education, 2023).




Conclusion: Simulate to Strengthen

Students can’t avoid conflict—but they can prepare for it. AI-generated scenarios provide a safe, scalable way to practice conflict resolution, try out different strategies, and reflect on consequences.

But empathy, listening, and compromise aren’t built by algorithms alone. These tools work best when embedded in teacher-guided conversations, peer interactions, and emotionally safe environments.

Used wisely, AI in conflict resolution education is not a shortcut—but a springboard into deeper understanding, courage, and compassion.



Want to learn more?

Check out our SEL Classroom Workbooks

Access classroom-ready turnkey resources for your SEL classroom.  Our SEL resources are crafted to be both engaging and interactive, aimed at nurturing empathy, compassion, and well-being among students. With a commitment to creating inclusive and kind classroom environments, our suite of print and digital materials is designed to support educators in this mission